Summative Portfolio – Next Logical Step

I started the semester planning a research project for my Modern Asia class instead of a final exam. That felt progressive to me, and it still does. That was what I had my class do last year, and it went well.

This year, I decided to ask my students what they wanted to learn. I blogged about that already. They gave me many good ideas, but what I realized is that there is enough common interest and desire to continue working together as a class, rather than dividing into projects. This class has a lot of questions and areas they want to learn about. We started down this path with the Khmer Rouge and Cambodia and now will look into post-Vietnam War Vietnam. This type of plan seemed to need a different type of summative assessment.

My idea is the summative portfolio – four pieces with four due dates that can be done in any order. There is a mix of common tasks and individualized work. I am hoping this plan will allow my seniors to keep learning what they want while they reflect on all that we have done. They will be able to synthesize and analyze content while they demonstrate the skills I hope they have acquired. Here is my draft version of the requirements – comments and suggestions welcome. I am already getting some helpful feedback from my librarian.

What is it I want students to know/demonstrate?

1. Ability to dissect and explain current events – either analyze one media source from one day in its entirety or choose an issue and several different news sources
2. Evaluation of book sources – Comparative Book Review (of two books read in course) – What each book contributed to understanding of China and India; strengths and weaknesses of each – show NYRB as example.
3. Knowledge of basic content about post-WWII India and Communist China (Content questions – “exam” from last year) – including comparative questions
4. Ability to do deep focused research to answer specific question

I hope that this allows students to demonstrate their learning in a way that is useful for them.


3 thoughts on “Summative Portfolio – Next Logical Step

  1. I also like the idea of a portfolio and your ideas about common expectations and set of skills cover a lot. I am curious about the discussion about the format or product for each of the ‘assessments’. Would expect them to in the form of an essay or could they write a podcast? Your entry is giving me ideas about what other ideas I could consider for my senior class instead of midterm assessment.

    • I had not really thought that much about the format of the product. For the comparative book review, I think I want a written essay. The research piece is still to be determined. It may be a bibliographic essay or an annotated bibliography. I am more flexible with the other two pieces, I think. I need to consider that a bit more.

      I may do an extended version of this for my second semester course – ten assessments, ten deadlines, to be done in any order. Just beginning to think about that. I would love to hear your ideas, Cristina.

      • I would love to get together and brainstorm. I would love to have my students create a newscast, similar to what I find in real Spanish TV and created for a real audience. I am finding often myself thinking about this type of projects and how to make them work in the foreign language classroom. At times I find that the openess of the PBL or self-guided learning is not always compatible with theories of the FL acquisition.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s